I broke my fast before sunset by mistake. What now?
Question · One of the most asked questions about Ramadan
It was cloudy and I thought the sun had already set, so I ate a date and drank some water. Then I realised it was still about ten minutes before Maghrib. Is my fast ruined?
Short answer
There is no sin in an honest mistake: stop eating at once and continue until sunset. Most scholars say you make up the day later, unless you ate because you forgot you were fasting.
Detailed answer
An honest mistake is not a sin. What you need to do depends on the kind of mistake:
- You forgot you were fasting: your fast is completely valid. Stop as soon as you remember and carry on. There is nothing to make up.
- You thought the sun had set, but it had not: stop eating immediately and continue fasting until sunset. According to most scholars, you should make up this one day after Ramadan. There is no sin and no kaffarah (expiation).
What the Quran and Sunnah say
Allah says: "There is no blame on you for the mistakes you make, but only for what your hearts intend" (Al-Ahzab 33:5). About forgetting, the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: "Whoever forgets while fasting and eats or drinks, let him complete his fast, for it is Allah who fed him and gave him drink" (Bukhari and Muslim).
About misjudging the time, Asma bint Abi Bakr reported that in the Prophet's time people once broke their fast on a cloudy day, and then the sun appeared (Bukhari). Most scholars understood from this and similar reports that the day should be made up. Some scholars hold that no make-up is needed, because the person acted on what they honestly believed; if you are unsure, ask a trusted local scholar.
In practice
- Stop eating and drinking the moment you realise.
- Continue fasting until Maghrib out of respect for the day.
- Write down the day so you can make it up before next Ramadan.
- Do not feel guilty: you did nothing wrong.
How to avoid it
Do not rely on the sky or on guesswork, especially on cloudy days or in unfamiliar places. Use a reliable timetable such as our prayer times page, and break your fast when Maghrib time begins. If you are with others, it helps when one person checks the time for everyone.
Read more about eating or drinking by mistake, how to make up missed fasts and when iftar time is.
These answers give the general ruling based on the Quran, the Sunnah and the mainstream view of scholars. For a personal situation, ask a qualified scholar you trust.
Ask your question
Could not find your question? Send it to us. We add answers to the most asked questions on this page.



